TMZ Live: Beyonce Goes Live ... but Way Too Far to Prove Her Point
Beyonce sticks it to the haters -- belting out the National Anthem ... LIVE! No doubt she can sing, but did the move seem a little desperate? The newsroom got loud and heated over that question. Plus, San Francisco 49er Chris Culliver made horribly…
Carrie Underwood Cat Power Catherine Bell Chandra West Charisma Carpenter Charli Baltimore Charlies Angels Charlize Theron